The Myth of Romance:
Study Guide
Leader's/Counselor's Copy
This material may be copied as needed provided: 1) the text is not altered except to
section it into manageable sizes and, 2) the authors' names appear on each copy of the
work.
You can also download this paper in Word for
Windows 6.0 format (zipped file, 20K)
By Dennis McCallum and Gary DeLashmutt
Leader's introduction
This study guide follows, chapter by chapter, the book, The Myth of Romance, by
Dennis McCallum and Gary DeLashmutt. We refer to ourselves in the third person in order to
keep the focus on the text. The guide is arranged for use in any one of four venues:
- Individual enrichment
- Couples premarital study
- Married couples' enrichment
- Group study
We have seen excellent results using this book as a basis for small group as
well as in premarital counseling. If using The Myth of Romance as a premarital
or marital counseling aid, you may want to read the chapter together before
going over the questions. For group leaders, the facilitator's guide provides
suggested answers or tips to key questions. The other three venues will have
no use for the facilitator's guide. Hundreds of couples planning their marriage
have reported that this study brought to light the issues God wanted to call
to their attention. May God use the material to richly bless your present or
future marriage as well as the other relationships in your life.
How to lead a group study based on this book:
First read the chapter from the book. Then come to this guide to deepen and apply the
principles you learn in the book. You can obtain copies of The Myth of Romance for each
member of the group either at your bookstore, or you get quantity pricing from the Xenos
web page (http://www.xenos.org/myth.html). Also, get both this facilitator's guide and the
discussion guide. Copy the pages from the discussion guide and pass them out, preferably a
week before the discussion on a given chapter. The facilitator may need to select which
questions to cover on a given chapter because covering all questions may take too long.
You can download for free either the leader's version or the group member or counselee
version (missing suggested answers) from the website mentioned above, or call
1-800-698-7884 and request they be sent to your address. Hard copies are not free like
soft copies, because paper, reproduction, mailing, and handling all cost. We charge our
cost only for hard copies.
Please feel free to send us feedback about problems or positive results by email, to
mccallumd@xenos.org, or delashmuttg@xenos.org, or come to the Xenos Web Site at
http://www.xenos.org, and send us response there.
Chapter 1
Marriage Success Today:
What Are Your Chances?
- Are you from an intact, or a broken family? How do you think this may have affected you,
and how have you adjusted?
- How could you imagine divorce possibly impacting children and their future marriages?
- Single parent families offer decreased nurture to kids creating adjustment problems
- Kids who see marriage fail may become cynical about marriage or even fearful
- Unless divorcees area cooperative with each other, kids may get a negative view of the
opposite sex
- Separation anxiety may cause kids to become insecure, depending on others for their
sense of security, leading to hyper-dependence
- The authors suggest it's possible to "prepare" for marriage. Do you find this
suggestion plausible? Or does it seem contrived?
- Think of other things we prepare for--job, parenting, sports
- Those who think we shouldn't have to prepare for marriage betray an underlying belief
that marriage should happen automatically--probably because of the eros myth
- The authors discuss the disturbing case of Esau. Record your reaction to the following:
God loves us and if we mess up he will fix our lives.
Agree Somewhat agree Doubtful Disagree
If we ignore God's will we may suffer disaster in this life.
Agree Somewhat agree Doubtful Disagree
- Marriage is harder than shining a pair of shoes. Before God, how far are you prepared to
go in making your marriage all it can be?
- You could share what you put on this question
Chapter 2
Is "Love" Enough?
- Have you ever had the experience of believing you were in love with someone, only to
find later that you no longer had any interest in that person? How do you interpret such
an experience?
- At the very least, this must suggest the unreliability of eros love as a guide to
the "will of God" or as a guide to finding everlasting love.
- If a couple are "in love," shouldn't they get married? Why, or why not?
- This question reveals people's reasons for getting married.
- What would be a good reason for getting married if not being in love?
- Ask the group, "What does being in love mean?"
- Have you ever known a couple who believed they were in love and got married, only to
fail? If so, what do you think accounts for the failure?
- Answers to this question could reveal more about how people interpret eros mythology.
Try to summarize the principle their answers imply.
- McCallum and DeLashmutt think Christian love has to do with serving others more than it
does with feelings. What do you think of the passages they cite on p. (The good Samaritan,
1John 3:17) to back this up?
- Observe that the Samaritan both felt compassion and did something about it.
- For those who think love is mainly a feeling, ask how this can be reconciled with the
biblical material. Isn't our modern definition of love more focused on feeling and
sentiment than the biblical view which focuses more on serving and giving?
- The authors mention married couples whose "love seems to desert them" after
marriage. Are you aware of any cases where this occurred? If so, what does it mean?
- Under the eros myth, it might suggest that they married by mistake and that their love
was not "the real thing."
- To biblical Christians, it should suggest the inadequacy of eros feelings for
discovering eternal love.
- Are you aware of any cases where a married person came to believe that he or she was in
love with another person other than their spouse? If so, what lesson(s) can be drawn from
such episodes?
- Again, eros feelings for another woman or man are impossible to distinguish from eros
feelings we originally felt for our spouse.
- Your friend says, "I wouldn't buy a car without driving it around the block, and I
wouldn't marry someone without a trial marriage." How would you assess such a
statement?
- That which is reasonable when buying a machine is hardly appropriate for a personal
being.
- Note the "self-first" ethos in this thought: "I have to check to make
sure I'm getting all I can get." This direction is seeking to take, not to give.
Chapter 3
What Does Christian Intimacy Look Like?
How would you rate yourself in the following areas:
(Circle the one that is most true)
- I'm a careful listener
Yes, very much
Average
An area of some weakness
- Committed and faithful in expending time on my relationships
Yes, very much
Average
An area of some weakness
- Able to share deeply in the emotional realm
Yes, very much
Average
An area of some weakness
- Able to get outside of myself and draw others out
Yes, very much
Average
An area of some weakness
- I'm a warm and enthusiastic person
Yes, very much
Average
An area of some weakness
- I avoid excessive "pigtail pulling" with my friends, and can express direct
affection
Yes, very much
Average
An area of some weakness
- I am able to take an interest in others' hobbies, sports or special interests
Yes, very much
Average
An area of some weakness
- I'm not afraid to confront others for their own good
Yes, very much
Average
An area of some weakness
- I am receptive to criticism from my friends
Yes, very much
Average
An area of some weakness
- I think and pray about my loved ones when I am not with them
Yes, very much
Average
An area of some weakness
- I don't look to other people for my sense of worth
Yes, very much
Average
An area of some weakness
- I control my feelings, avoiding unnecessarily hurtful expressions
Yes, very much
Average
An area of some weakness
- I feel good about my ability to help my loved ones maximize their potential
Yes, very much
Average
An area of some weakness
- I often encourage my loved ones, and let them know I love them
Yes, very much
Average
An area of some weakness
Check your work
- If you are studying with a fiancé or spouse, compare your answers. Do each of you agree
with the other's self-assessment? Discuss any differences.
- If you are studying with a group, you need not say which one you circled unless you want
to. Discuss what someone who feels weak in each area could do to develop more in that
area.
- In a group you could ask if anyone wants to share their mark, or ask "Did anyone
feel they were strong in this area?" Or "Did anyone besides me mark this as a
weak area?"
- Focus time on the second part of question #2.
Chapter 4
Learning Christian Love
- Do you agree with the authors that people need the experience of building one or more
successful intimate relationships (non-romantic) before they can feel confident they will
succeed in marriage? Why or why not?
- For those who answer no, why do they think they will be able to do something in marriage
that they have not been able to do before marriage? (see #3 below)
- For those who feel intimate relationships with dating partners is adequate, ask whether
they believe the feelings that now buttress that relationship will continue to do so
within marriage? Do they feel they are different than other married couples?
- Can you suggest an alternative capability that would point toward likely marriage
success?
- Respond to the authors' question: "If we are not successfully loving people at the
intimate level before marriage, what makes us think we will be able to do so after
marriage?"
- The authors also say: "Likewise, if we are married, but find no examples of
intimate relationship outside our marriage, perhaps the problem is not with our spouse
after all!" What are they suggesting? Do you agree?
- Married people having relational problems tend to blame their spouses. But if none of
their other relationships are successful at an intimate level, perhaps they themselves are
unable to relate at an intimate level.
- Help your married members turn their eyes away from blaming their spouses and onto
themselves.
- Do your own relational inventory. What areas do you see as areas of strength? What areas
need improvement?
Chapter 5
Growing Together:
Marriage and Community
- Biblical teachings about modesty suggest that privacy is appropriate in a marriage
relationship. Yet, as the authors show, marriage is often cast in the context of Christian
community. Where do you see the boundaries between the privacy of the marital relationship
and the shared life of the Christian community?
Try to imagine things that might be inappropriate in the direction of encroachment by the
community into marriage:
Try to imagine things that might be inappropriate in the direction of unqualified
individualism and privacy:
- The purpose of these questions are to make members wrestle with the issue of privacy
versus community.
- Would you ask counsel of older Christians on your readiness for marriage? Or do you feel
this is an area that is nobody else's business?
- Why should marriage be the only major decision in life for which we ask no advice?
Probably, those who feel no one can advise them on this question are betraying a belief in
the eros myth-- "Others cannot help because they can't possibly tell how deep our
love feelings are."
- Why do the authors think parents and older Christians are a source of counsel but not a
"chain of authority?" What is the difference? Do you agree?
- Be aware of the desire of some to offload responsibility for tough,
dangerous and scary decisions. Stress the union of responsibility and
decision-making authority: Who will live with the outcome of the decision?
- Would orthodox Muslim parents ever agree to a Christian marriage?
- Are you aware of any time when a troubled marriage was helped by the Christian
community?
- Many married couples report being helped by other Christian married couples. If this is
not the case in your church, it may be a sad comment on the level of intimacy in that
community. Perhaps your group will be different!
- Is your own involvement in body life superficial? Do you merely go to meetings? Or are
you vitally involved in relationships and ministry? What are some steps you could take to
upgrade your level of involvement?
- Begin with theological and moral convictions. Find like-minded people, or convince
others. Begin devoting time and energy to one another in meetings and other venues to
develop body life.
Chapter 6
Competent to Give:
Marriage and Ministry
- DeLashmutt and McCallum say that the same things that prevent people from developing a
successful ministry also create problems in marriage. How true do you think this is?
- For your own ministry(s) mark for each of the following features from The Myth of
Romance, your current standing:
(Circle the one that is most true)
Ministry Should Be Concrete
Yes, my mine is
Partially true
Not really
Ministry Should Include the Personal
Yes, my mine is
Partially true
Not really
We Should Be Able to Minister Separately
Yes, my mine is
Partially true
Not really
We Should Be Able to Minister When Together
Yes, my mine is
Partially true
Not really
- Check to see if those marking "not really" see this as a problem, or as the
way it should be.
- For each of the categories above you marked as partially or not true, think of ways you
could possibly upgrade your involvement:
Ministry Should Be Concrete
Ministry Should Include the Personal
We Should Be Able to Minister Separately
We Should Be Able to Minister When Together
- This question lends itself to discussion more than the first.
- Do you agree with the authors' claim that a couple who minister only to their own family
is engaging in corporate selfishness? Does God call us to serve others outside our family?
- In the American evangelical church, ministry to one's family is often considered
sufficient. Indeed some church leaders feel lucky if they can extract even this from their
preoccupied members. The result is that all other types of ministry are left to the
professionals or to singles.
- "The best time to get married is when two people feel that both will be more
effective for Christ married than single." How do you react to this statement?
Chapter 7
Building on a Solid Foundation
- The authors claim, "Many dating couples erroneously believe that positive spiritual
habits will be easier to develop after they are married. In fact, the opposite is often
true." Do you believe that married couples find themselves sharing, praying etc. less
than they did when single? If you are single, interview several married couples and raise
this question. What do they say?
- For dating or engaged couples, assess where you stand as a couple in each of these areas
recommended by the authors. For each recommendation, check the statement you identify with
most:
Encourage Independent Growth
Neither of us are possessive. We both pursue independent growth.
One of us is a bit possessive. We are not always free to pursue independent growth
We don't see the importance of independent growth. We believe we are trying for
forge unity, not independence.
Regular Scheduled Time
We schedule time at least weekly for spiritual sharing.
We don't schedule time, but we do well with spontaneous sharing and prayer.
We hope to see improvement in this area.
Seek to Balance One Another
We find that we compliment each other's strengths and weaknesses.
We are similar in strengths and weaknesses, so this doesn't apply to us.
We sometimes experience tension over our different ways of expressing our
spirituality.
Mutual Respect and Patience
We both feel secure even sharing deeply about our weaknesses
We have had a few problems feeling judged by each other, but not many.
We know we need to work on this area.
Build Common Ministry
We serve together once in awhile.
We don't have this now, but we hope to have it later.
- Ask if anyone wants to share where they checked one of the second, or third-level boxes.
If you can get people to offer their answers and discuss them, together often, and that
leads to shared burdens for prayer study and sharing.
We get to when, but don't push them to share against their will.
- Why would a Christian dating partner or fiancé resist praying, sharing or studying
Scripture together? Can you think of a possible motive other than those suggested by the
authors? How serious do you think this problem is?
- The authors say it's always wrong for a Christian to marry a nonChristian. Do you
agree? Why or why not?
- Find out whether your members feel bound by the authority of Scripture. Are their
arguments against this idea (if any) exegetical? or experiential?
- Do you know any couples who are "unequally yoked" either in the sense that one
is Christian and the other is nonChristian, or that one is interested in spiritual things
and the other is not? How is that situation working out? Would you consider entering such
a future yourself?
- What would you say to a Christian about to marry either a nonChristian or an
disinterested Christian in the belief that things will change after marriage?
Chapter 8
Sexual Love or Exploitation?
- The authors say, "Married sexuality will never conform to the standards of modern
pornography." Name some ways in which married sex is different from pornography and
different from the sex relationships portrayed in porno-type media.
- The stimulation of immorality is absent
- Our physical appearance can rarely measure up to the models in movies and magazines
- Sex with someone you live with and relate to in an ongoing way involves resolving
conflicts and nurturing good feelings in the relationship, unlike casual sex, where you
walk away from each other after the act.
- In real, marital sexuality, the insecurities and emotional needs of the other must be
constantly considered, whereas in the make-believe sex of porno, others have no emotional
needs other than sexual desire.
- Think of others. . .
- The authors also list some factors that successful married couples say are key to sexual
success. For each feature, try to imagine (without getting graphic) what sort of
problem(s) might be generated if this feature is missing:
mutual trust [distrust can lead to frigidity or impotence]
vulnerability [if we sense our partner only wants to relate sexually, not personally, we
feel used]
security based on a lifelong commitment [we have difficulty responding freely
unless we know we are secure]
ongoing personal sharing [personal closeness leads to sexual responsiveness]
sexual self-control [inability to control one's sexual desires may lead to harmful
aggression, masturbation, or lack of sensitivity, all of which may crush sexual
responsiveness]
- Is it carnal to want your spouse to have a pleasant looking body?
- Some feel this way. They feel their spouses should appreciate and desire them sexually,
even though they have not exerted any effort to look attractive.
- Over-eating could be a way to "get back" at an insensitive, violent, or
unloving spouse.
- McCallum and DeLashmutt claim, "Those who practice premarital sex on
an ongoing basis are also deliberately reserving the right to exit the relationship
easily, should they decide to. In other words, when someone calls on you for
premarital sex, he is really saying, 'I want to use your body to meet my sexual
appetite, but I want to remain free to reject you afterward.'" Can you
suggest a different motive for premarital sex?
- Does loss of sexual self-control necessarily inhibit communication in a dating
relationship? Does it necessarily inhibit development of good spiritual habits?
- Perhaps if an incident is isolated and is resolved spiritually immediately, the harm
might be minimal. However, honest singles will admit that sexual immorality is very
damaging most of the time.
Chapter 9
Are We Moving in the Same Direction?
- The authors claim that the Bible teaches different sexual roles for men and women in
marriage, including male leadership. Do you agree? Why or why not?
- Are the views your members share exegetical (i.e. how the Bible reads) or
experiential/affective (e.g. "look how bossy men misuse these verses" or
"this kind of claim just makes me sick!")? What role should biblical teaching
have in framing our answer to this question?
- For those who feel gender roles in marriage are just a cultural issue, like giving one
another a holy kiss, why are the statements on roles grounded in the theology of the Old
Testament rather than in cultural norms (Eph. 5:24ff; 1 Tim. 2)?
- Why do the authors think centering a marriage around God's authority is a basis for
closeness?
- Provides a basis for resolving conflicts
- Provides a basis for seeking goals other than "what I want"
- Name some of the limitations you see on the idea of headship in marriage.
- Only applies to that which does not contradict higher authority
- Should be exercised only in the context of self-giving love
- The authors say, "Our postmodern aversion to authority is incompatible with
Christianity, not only because it flies in the face of biblical teaching, but because it
is based on our fear of corrupt and self-serving authority figures." How significant
do you think "aversion to authority" is in our culture? Do you ever struggle
with aversion to authority?
- The authors also say, "Both partners in a marriage should understand and agree on
their concept of headship before getting married." If you are engaged, do you agree?
Chapter 10
Overcoming Obstacles from the Past: Relationships
- DeLashmutt and McCallum say that romantic love is blind. What do they mean by this?
Drawing from your own experience in this area, do you agree with this assertion?
- Eros love feelings are so strong that they tend to create an idealized picture of
the loved one, filtering out character flaws and other personal problems. Couples who are
"in love" also tend to put their best foot forward and relate to each other in
very positive settings.
- Perhaps those in the group have experienced sudden and distressing changes in their
feelings about their romantic partners. Ask them to share this along with how they
responded to it and what they learned from this experience.
- How can you gain a more realistic assessment of the other person before marriage?
- Delay serious decisions (engagement, marriage) until the eros feelings die down
enough to get a more objective picture. Sometimes you can do this by taking the dating
relationship slowly. If the relationship has become too "hot and heavy" it may
be wise to take a break from the relationship in order to get some objectivity.
- Focus on what others say about the person. Ask friends and mature people who know you
both for some honest feedback.
- Probe more deeply when you see something problematic instead of ignoring it.
- Take an honest inventory of the sexual damage you have incurred. What kinds of sexual
sin have you been involved in? To what extent and over how long a period of time? What
negative effects can you identify? How much healing has occurred in this area? What
negative effects should you look out for in marriage?
- The key here is to be honest about your problems in this area, while also affirming the
power of God to change you.
- Close friends are a big help in considering this issue. They will often have insight on
these questions, and they can also encourage you.
- When would be the best time to frankly discuss each other's past sexual involvement?
- Shortly before engagement seems best. We should resist lengthy and detailed sharing in
this area until we know (on the basis of things discussed in this book) we are both ready
for marriage. This kind of intimate confession tends to deepen couples' commitment to one
another, whereas the decision to become committed should be made on other bases.
- In the meantime, we should share this area with our close Christian friends.
- Can you clearly articulate how you contributed to the failure of your marriage or
serious romantic relationships? How have you made progress in these areas?
- Inability to answer this question may indicate that we need to do some praying and
careful thinking about this area.
- For engaged and married couples, discuss your relationships with both sets of parents.
Do you foresee or are you experiencing problems with them? If so, have you discussed them?
Devise a plan for how you can address these problems and still initiate genuine love
toward them.
- Check these areas:
- unresolved resentments that should be forgiven
- lack of loving investment on their part or yours
- failure to stand against parental manipulation
- failure to discipline in love
Chapter 11
Overcoming Obstacles From the Past: Addictions, Materialism, and Psychological Damage
- For those who have a history of alcohol or drug abuse, consider the following questions:
How did this sin area affect your relational life?
How long have you been free from actual abuse?
How have you, or are you, replaced(ing) the stimulation you got from drug or alcohol
abuse?
How are your relationships now different from when you abused?
- Take an honest inventory of the questions posed concerning materialism and circle the
response that fits best:
I experience conflict between my materialistic and my spiritual desires.
Yes, a lot
Some, not too bad
I can't relate to this
My private fantasies of the "ideal life" often include a lot of expensive things
Yes, a lot
Some, not too bad
I can't relate to this
When spiritual and secular responsibilities and opportunities conflict I often find myself
thinking that I dare not say "no" to the secular.
Yes, a lot
Some, not too bad
I can't relate to this
I'm not really content with what I have materially.
Yes, a lot
Some, not too bad
I can't relate to this
I sometimes forget to distinguish between "wants" and "needs."
Yes, a lot
Some, not too bad
I can't relate to this
I'm carrying quite a bit of commercial credit debt.
Yes, a lot
Some, not too bad
I can't relate to this
I regularly and generously give my money to God's service.
Yes, a lot
Some, not too bad
I can't relate to this
I have trouble articulating my short-term and long-term spiritual goals.
Yes, a lot
Some, not too bad
I can't relate to this
- How would you describe your view retirement?
I probably worry about this more than I should
I prepare for retirement, but I'm not sure it's too much
I'm not worried about it, and my preparations are adequate
- For seriously dating or engaged couples, discuss all history of serious psychological
problems. What help have you received for these problems? To what extent are they under
control?
- Problems are "under control" when they do not substantially interfere with our
ability to sustain close love relationships.
Chapter 12
Personal Maturity
- If you are single, have you ever spent a significant time as a Christian without
romantic involvement? If so, what has God taught you about trusting him and about your own
character during this time?
- Those who have responded to the trial of loneliness properly will be thankful for that
trial because they have learned such valuable lessons. The lessons may include: increased
confidence that God will truly meet their needs, a lifestyle built around love-giving
rather than love-taking, sexual self-control, and transformation of character issues that
affect relational ability (forgiveness; loving confrontation; emotional sensitivity;
active listening).
- If you are serious dating or engaged, explain why you are confident that your partner is
committed to spiritual maturity.
- Watch to see if the answers are only subjective (I can just feel his love for God) or if
they include the objective. We should be able to point to concrete things like successful
close love relationships with other people, deepening involvement in the Word, fellowship,
prayer, and Christian ministry.
- Take inventory of your maturity in functional responsibility by circling the response
that fits best:
My fiscal management has kept me out of trouble with credit, met my needs and included a
good giving ministry
Not really
Sort of. . .
Yes, for the most part
My performance at school has been adequate to earn the degrees I wanted
Not really
Sort of. . .
Yes, for the most part
My performance at work satisfies my employers. If I have changed jobs, it was my choice,
not because I got fired or pressured out.
Not really
Sort of. . .
Yes, for the most part
I maintain my household and transportation in good shape, safe and presentable to guests
and neighbors.
Not really
Sort of. . .
Yes, for the most part
- If you have problems here, what practical steps can you take to improve?
Chapter 13
Balance and Direction
We leave this chapter to you to discuss. The issues are simple and it may very well be
included with the previous chapter in group study or counseling.
We hope you enjoyed your study of The Myth of Romance. You may also benefit from
similar study guides for the authors' other books. These books and study guides are all
available at the Xenos web site, or at your local bookstore.
Other Books by Dennis McCallum:
Other Books by Gary DeLashmutt
Return to the Myth of Romance page
Return to the Xenos home page
